Why Do I Keep Looking for Advice When I Feel Stuck in Midlife?
Many women in midlife find themselves repeatedly looking for advice when they feel stuck. Whether it’s searching for purpose, clarity, or direction, the instinct is to turn outward for answers. This article explores why that habit forms — and why self-trust, not more information, is often what’s actually missing.
Maybe you’re not confused. Maybe you’ve just been listening everywhere but yourself.
Dr. Oksana Skidan
The other day, I typed a simple phrase into Google: “How to find your purpose.”
In less than a second, hundreds of results appeared — quizzes, five-step frameworks, personality tests, career pivots, spiritual awakenings, and masterclasses promising clarity in thirty days.
If so many results exist, it means one thing: we are asking.
Women everywhere, especially in midlife, are sitting in quiet moments of uncertainty and typing the same questions into search bars. Not because they are dramatic. Not because they are incapable. But because something inside feels unsettled, and the fastest response is to look outward for answers.
It usually starts small. You feel stuck, but you can’t fully explain why. Something feels off. Maybe it’s your work. Maybe it’s your marriage. Maybe it’s a deeper question about who you are becoming after 40. Before you sit with the discomfort, your hand reaches for your phone.
You start searching:
“Why don’t I know what I want?”
“How to find your purpose in midlife.”
“What should I do next with my life?”
“Why do I feel stuck in my 40s?”
Or you open a podcast app. You scroll through episodes looking for someone who sounds confident and certain. You read another article. You bookmark another guide. You gather advice, information, and other people’s clarity.
And yet, there is one thing many of us rarely do. We don’t pause long enough to ask ourselves.
This isn’t because you lack intelligence or discipline. It isn’t weakness. It isn’t social media addiction. It’s a pattern. When you don’t know something, you automatically look outside for the answer.
I call this the External Answer Habit.
If you prefer listening, explore The Create Your Midlife™ podcast for thoughtful conversations on midlife, self-trust, and creating what comes next.
What Is the External Answer Habit (And Why It Keeps You Feeling Stuck)?
The External Answer Habit is simple, but powerful. It’s the reflex to believe that clarity lives somewhere outside you — in a book, a podcast, a course, or an expert who seems more certain than you feel.
When you’re feeling stuck in midlife, this reflex becomes automatic. Instead of sitting with uncertainty, you search for advice. In a world full of “how-to” content, it feels completely normal to assume that the answer must already exist somewhere. If you just read one more article or listen to one more episode, you’ll finally know what to do next.
This habit feels responsible. It feels productive. It even feels mature. Gathering information is a sign of intelligence, and learning from others is how we grow. That’s why this pattern is so difficult to recognize. It doesn’t look like avoidance. It looks like effort.
The problem isn’t that outside advice is wrong. The problem is that we use it for the wrong kind of question. When you need to solve something practical — how to negotiate a salary, improve your health, or learn a new skill — external answers are useful. But when the question is about identity, purpose, or who you are becoming after 40, no amount of outside content can replace your own internal clarity.
At some point, the issue is no longer a lack of information. It’s a lack of self-trust.
Having trouble sleeping? This blog offers a very untraditional approach to sleep - Sleep Problems in Midlife: Why Women Over 40 Still Struggle — Even When They Know What to Do
Why We’re Conditioned to Look Outside for Answers (Especially in Midlife)
From childhood, this is how we learned to move through the world. If you didn’t know something, you asked your parents. Curiosity was answered by someone older, wiser, or more certain. The message was simple: if you don’t know, someone else does.
At school, the pattern continued. If you didn’t understand, you asked the teacher. If you wanted good grades, you studied the book. The answers were in the curriculum, in the textbook, in the authority at the front of the room. Learning meant looking outward. Progress meant absorbing what had already been defined.
As adults, the same structure follows us. You ask experts about your career, doctors about your health, advisors about your finances. There is nothing wrong with that. Seeking informed guidance is intelligent and necessary. We cannot be specialists in everything, and external expertise helps us function in a complex world. But over time, this practical habit becomes something deeper.
It becomes a belief: if I don’t know the answer,
it must exist somewhere outside me.
That formula works beautifully for technical or professional questions. It begins to fail when the questions become personal — especially in midlife. When you start asking, “Why do I feel stuck?” or “What do I want now?” you are no longer looking for information. You are looking for identity. And identity cannot be outsourced.
Why Feeling Stuck Gets Stronger in Midlife
In midlife, the questions change.
By the time many women reach their 40s or early 50s, the culturally approved path has often been completed. We earned the degree. We built the career. We raised the children. From the outside, the major milestones are in place. Life looks stable — sometimes even successful.
And then a different kind of question rises.
Who am I now?
What do I want next?
Why do I feel stuck in midlife when everything looks fine?
What actually matters to me at this stage of life?
These are not practical questions. They are identity questions.
Identity is shaped by your lived experience — your disappointments,
your strengths, your private longings.
You can Google how to change careers in your 40s, but you cannot Google whether that change will feel meaningful to you. You can search for “how to find your purpose in midlife,” but no search result can tell you what will genuinely satisfy you. You can listen to experts discuss reinvention, confidence, or courage. In the end, you are still the one who has to decide.
So what do many women do when they feel uncertain or stuck? We consume more. More books. More podcasts. More masterclasses. More advice. I did this for years. Whenever I felt restless or unclear, I assumed someone else must have figured it out better than I had.
The problem wasn’t that those voices were wrong. Many were wise and thoughtful. The problem was that they were describing how they would navigate their lives. Their clarity was shaped by their personalities, histories, and values. It could not be a blueprint for mine.
I was using an information tool for an identity search — hoping that
someone else’s certainty would replace my own self-trust.
Continue reading - Self-Belief in Midlife: Why Women Over 40 Struggle to Trust Themselves
Why Do I Still Feel Stuck Even After Reading Self-Help Books?
There is a quiet cost to constantly looking for advice, and many women in midlife don’t notice it at first. You read the self-help books. You listen to the podcasts. You follow the experts. You compare perspectives and think carefully about each one. And yet, you still feel stuck.
Instead of moving forward, you remain in preparation mode. You feel productive because you are learning, but you are not actually deciding. You are absorbing. You are collecting ideas about how to live — without fully choosing your own direction.
Over time, this creates a subtle tension. You feel informed but not settled. You understand many strategies for change, yet none of them feel fully yours. Decisions are postponed because there is always one more angle to consider, one more book to read, one more opinion to weigh. Clarity feels close, but never quite solid.
This is not fear. It is not incompetence. It is misplaced authority.
When you expect answers to come primarily from outside yourself, your own voice begins to soften. The more external opinions you collect, the harder it becomes to hear your own perspective clearly. You start to doubt what you already know because it hasn’t been validated by someone else.
The deeper issue is not a lack of knowledge. By midlife, you carry decades of lived experience, insight, and personal history. The real shift begins when you notice that you have been trained to trust outside voices more than your own self-trust. Even when something inside you quietly knows the direction, you hesitate. You pause. You reach outward first instead of listening inward.
Explore my free resources and continue creating your midlife, your way.
What If the Answer Is Already Inside You?
What if the answer isn’t missing?
What if you were never taught to ask yourself first?
Many women who feel stuck in midlife assume they need better advice, a clearer plan, or more expert guidance. But what if clarity isn’t something you go out and find — what if it’s something you finally allow yourself to hear?
What if the reason you feel stuck isn’t confusion, but noise? Noise from too many opinions. Too many strategies. Too many voices telling you how to live.
Pause there.
Before you open another tab or search for more advice, ask yourself one simple question:
What do I already know?
That question is uncomfortable because it shifts authority back to you.
How to Trust Yourself in Midlife (Without Looking for More Advice)
Midlife is not a knowledge problem. It is an authority shift.
By our forties and fifties, we have lived long enough to carry real experience. We have made decisions. We have seen consequences. We have succeeded and adjusted and rebuilt. This is not a stage of starting from zero. It is a stage of recognizing that your lived experience has value.
But self-trust in midlife does not activate automatically. For decades, we have been conditioned to look outward first. So when we feel uncertain, we search. When we feel stuck, we ask for advice. When we feel restless, we look for someone else’s clarity.
Shifting that pattern is subtle but powerful.
It is the movement from external answers to internal ones.
From asking, “What do they think I should do?” to asking,
“What feels true for me now?”
This does not require another method or framework. It begins with awareness. Before you search for advice, notice the impulse. Before you outsource your uncertainty, sit with the question. You may still choose to seek guidance later, but you begin with yourself.
You do not need more information to move forward in midlife. You need to stop assuming that your answers live somewhere else.
Self-trust grows when you allow your own experience to count. Not because you reject outside wisdom — but because you no longer place it above your own.
Thank you for reading. I’m so glad you’re here — and I hope you’ll come back for more encouragement and practical ideas about creating your midlife.
If you’d like more inspiration and guidance on how to Create Your Midlife, subscribe to The Create Letter — my free weekly newsletter for women creating their midlife, one choice at a time.
FAQs About Self-Belief in Midlife
1. Why do I keep looking for advice when I feel stuck?
Because most of us were trained to believe that answers live outside of us. When uncertainty appears, especially in midlife, the automatic response is to search for guidance, information, or expert opinions instead of pausing to ask ourselves first.
2. Why do I still feel stuck even after reading self-help books?
Self-help books provide strategies and perspectives, but they cannot answer personal identity questions. If the real issue is self-trust or direction in midlife, more information will not create clarity. At some point, the shift must move from gathering advice to listening inward.
3. Is it wrong to ask for advice when I feel stuck?
No. External guidance is valuable for practical problems. The issue arises when we use outside advice to solve deeply personal questions about purpose, identity, or what we want next in life. Those answers cannot be outsourced.
4. Why does feeling stuck become more common in midlife?
In midlife, many of the traditional milestones have already been reached. Once external structure is in place, deeper questions surface: Who am I now? What do I want next? These are identity questions, not information problems, which is why Googling them often doesn’t bring relief.
5. How can I start trusting myself in midlife?
Self-trust begins by noticing the reflex to search outside first. Before seeking more advice, pause and ask what you already know. Trust grows when your own lived experience is given equal weight to outside opinions.
6. Where do I begin?
Start with a pause. Download my Free Create Your Midlife™ Resources, listen to the latest Create Your Midlife™ Podcast, and subscribe to The Create Letter™ — your weekly reminder that midlife is not a race. It’s your season to create forward, one intentional choice at a time.